Best Rate Guarantee isn't the same as a price drop. Here's the difference.
When you start paying attention to hotel prices after booking, it's natural to assume the "Best Rate Guarantee" is how you get money back if the price goes down. It isn't. They're two different situations with two different fixes, and mixing them up wastes time.
The one I actually use: the price drop. Points Repricer, the Chrome extension I built, watches my bookings on the programs' own sites and tells me when the same room on the same rate gets cheaper, with the right way to claim it for that program. No forms, no waiting for approval. Join the waiting list
The Best Rate Guarantee: a lower price somewhere else
Each of the big chains has some version of this:
- Marriott: Best Rate Guarantee
- Hilton: Price Match Guarantee
- IHG: Best Price Guarantee
- Hyatt: Best Rate Guarantee
The idea is the same. If you book direct and then find the same room, same dates, same conditions for less on a different website (an online travel agency, for example), you can file a claim. Usually you have to do it within a short window, often 24 hours of booking, and the cheaper rate has to be publicly bookable and comparable (same cancellation terms, same room type).
If the claim is approved, the chain matches the price, and some add a bonus on top. The exact rules, windows and rewards differ by chain and change over time, so always read the current terms on the chain's own site before filing.
Why rate guarantee claims are hard to win
- The window is short. You need to find the lower price almost immediately.
- The match has to be exact. Same room, same cancellation terms, same number of guests, same total once taxes are compared. Many lower prices elsewhere turn out to be non-refundable or a slightly different room.
- It's reviewed. Someone checks your claim, and it can be turned down.
- Exclusions. Member-only, package, opaque and some promotional rates are often excluded.
That's not to say they never work. But they're a lot of effort for an uncertain result.
A price drop: a lower price on the same site, later
This is the one that comes up far more often. You book a refundable rate on Marriott.com, and three weeks later Marriott.com is selling the same room on the same rate for less.
No guarantee covers that. But you don't need one. Because the booking is refundable, you can:
- change the booking to today's price (Marriott, and IHG cash bookings via Modify), or
- book again at the lower price and cancel the original (Hilton, Hyatt, IHG reward nights).
Nobody has to approve it. You just do it, as long as you're inside the cancellation window. I go through each program in what I do when a hotel price drops.
Side by side
| Best Rate Guarantee | Price drop | |
|---|---|---|
| Where the lower price is | Another website | The hotel's own site |
| When | Usually within about 24 hours of booking | Any time before the cancellation deadline |
| How you claim | Fill in a claim form, wait for approval | Change or rebook it yourself |
| What you need | A comparable public rate elsewhere | A refundable (or changeable) booking |
| Works for points bookings? | Generally no | Yes, if the points price drops |
| Who decides | The chain | You |
Which one matters more to me
Honestly, the price drop. I book direct, so I keep my points earning and elite benefits, and I rarely see a properly comparable lower rate elsewhere within a day. But refundable bookings drift around in price over the weeks and months before a stay, and claiming those is entirely in my hands.
How to tell which one you're looking at
Ask two questions:
- Where is the lower price? On another site: rate guarantee territory. On the program's own site: it's a price drop.
- How long since you booked? More than a day or so, and a rate guarantee claim is probably out of time. A price drop can be claimed right up to the cancellation deadline.
Where Points Repricer fits
Points Repricer is built for the second case:
- It watches the programs' own sites, where my bookings are, for Marriott, IHG, Hilton and Hyatt, on points and cash.
- It checks like for like: same room, same rate plan, same tax basis. That's the same strictness a rate guarantee would apply, but for a lower price you can claim without anyone's approval.
- It checks several rooms if I've ticked ones I'd happily take, and uses the cheapest.
- It tells me how to claim for that program.
It doesn't file rate guarantee claims.
It runs on my own computer, in my own Chrome, and only does what I tell it. My bookings stay in my browser and are never sent to PointsRelated or anyone else.
It's a Chrome extension, not out yet.
Quick answers
Can I use the Best Rate Guarantee if the hotel's own price drops?
Generally no. That's a price drop; you change or rebook instead.
Does the Best Rate Guarantee work on points bookings?
Generally no. Price drops on points bookings can be claimed by changing or rebooking.
Is it worth filing a rate guarantee claim?
Sometimes, if you find a clearly comparable lower rate elsewhere right after booking. Read the terms carefully first.
PointsRelated isn't affiliated with Marriott, Hilton, IHG or Hyatt. Guarantee terms change; read the current terms on each chain's site.