Why I almost always book the refundable hotel rate
When I book a hotel, there's nearly always a cheaper option sitting right above the one I pick. Prepaid. Non-refundable. Advance purchase. Sometimes it's 10 or 15 percent less.
I still pick the refundable rate most of the time. Here's my thinking, the simple test I use, and the times I don't.
Why refundable works for me: I use Points Repricer, a Chrome extension I built, to watch my refundable bookings. It tells me when the same room on the same rate gets cheaper, and it also shows me when a cheaper non-refundable rate is available for my stay, so I can switch once my plans are fixed. Join the waiting list
What you're really paying for
A refundable rate isn't only insurance against plans changing. It's also what lets you take advantage of the price going down later.
If I book refundable and the same room on the same rate gets cheaper before my cancellation deadline, I can move to the lower price. If I book non-refundable, the price I paid is the price I pay, even if the hotel is selling the room for much less a month later.
So the refundable rate gives me two things:
- I can cancel if my plans change.
- I can rebook if the price drops.
Most comparisons only talk about the first one.
The different kinds of rate
Hotel sites use lots of names, but they boil down to a few types:
- Flexible / pay at the hotel. Cancel free up to a deadline (often 24 to 72 hours before arrival). Pay when you stay.
- Member rate. Usually a flexible rate with a small discount for being signed in to the loyalty program. Often the best default.
- Advance purchase / prepaid / non-refundable. Paid up front, can't be canceled or changed without losing the money. Cheapest.
- Package rates (breakfast, parking, credits). Can be flexible or not; read the terms.
A quick way to compare
Here's a simple way I think about it. These are made-up numbers just to show the idea:
- Refundable rate: $220 a night
- Non-refundable rate: $190 a night
- Difference: $30 a night, or $90 on a three-night stay.
The question is whether the flexibility is worth $90 to me. Two things push the answer:
- How likely my plans are to change. If there's a real chance I won't go, the refundable rate protects the whole $660.
- How likely the price is to fall. If the trip is months away, there's time for the rate to move. If the refundable rate drops by more than $30 a night at some point, I'd have done better than the non-refundable rate anyway.
If the trip is next week and nothing will change, the non-refundable rate is probably the better deal.
When I do book non-refundable
I'm not religious about it. I'll book a non-refundable rate when:
- The trip is certain and soon, so there's little time for the price to move.
- The discount is big, not just a few dollars.
- It's a busy date (a big event, a holiday weekend) where prices are much more likely to go up than down.
The middle path I use most
Book refundable early, then switch to the cheaper non-refundable rate once my plans are locked in. That way I keep flexibility while things are uncertain, catch any drops along the way, and still get the lower price at the end if I want it.
The catch is that I need to know when the non-refundable rate is worth switching to, which means checking it as well.
Points bookings are different
Most award bookings at Marriott, Hilton, IHG and Hyatt can be canceled for a points refund up to the property's deadline. That's one reason I like paying with points when the value is decent: the flexibility is built in. And since award prices move too, a points booking can get cheaper after you book.
How Points Repricer handles rates
Points Repricer is built around refundable bookings, because that's where a price drop can actually be claimed:
- Like-for-like checks. Every day it compares my booking with the same room, the same rate plan and the same tax basis. A cheaper prepaid rate never shows up as a fake "drop".
- Cheaper ways to rebook. Separately, it shows other rate plans for the same stay that cost less right now, like a non-refundable rate. They're kept apart from real drops because switching means giving up flexibility. That's my call to make, and I like seeing the option.
- More than one room. I can tick other rooms I'd happily take. It checks my rate in all of them and uses the cheapest.
- Sale prices flagged. If a lower price is a promotional or sale rate rather than my rate getting cheaper, it's tagged as a sale, not something to claim.
It runs on my own computer, in my own Chrome, and only does what I ask. It never changes a booking for me. My bookings stay in my browser and are never sent to PointsRelated or anyone else.
It's a Chrome extension, not released yet.
Quick answers
Is a refundable hotel rate worth it?
Usually, when the trip is more than a few weeks away or plans aren't certain. The flexibility also lets you rebook if the price falls.
Can I get a refund on a non-refundable rate if the price drops?
Generally not. Some hotels will help if you ask nicely, but there's no obligation.
Is the member rate refundable?
Often, but not always. Check the cancellation policy shown for that rate before you book.
Related: what I do when a hotel price drops after booking and do hotel prices drop closer to the date?